How to Throw a Tomahawk and a Thumber in Disc Golf
How to Throw a Tomahawk and a Thumber in Disc Golf
This post contains affiliate links. We may earn a commission if you purchase through our links, at no extra cost to you. As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases.
A basket sits behind a wall of trees, and the backhand gap barely exists. There is room above the canopy, though—and enough landing space for a disc to come down steeply. That is where a tomahawk or thumber can earn its place in your game.
Both are overhand throws, but their grips produce different flight paths. Learning both gives you two ways around an obstacle without forcing a low-percentage forehand flex. The buying question is straightforward: which disc gives you a secure grip, a usable turnover, and a landing you can plan around?
This guide uses published manufacturer specifications to compare four established molds. It does not report hands-on testing, and flight descriptions are tendencies rather than measured results.
How do you throw a tomahawk and a thumber in disc golf?
Throw a tomahawk with two fingers inside the rim and your thumb on the flight plate; throw a thumber with your thumb inside the rim and fingers outside. Release the disc nearly vertical using a smooth overhand motion, allowing enough height for its sideways rotation.
The Five Factors That Matter
Grip security comes before speed
For a tomahawk, place your index and middle fingers against the inside rim, with your thumb pressing the flight plate from the opposite side. Your remaining fingers can curl comfortably outside the rim. Some players use a single-finger variation, but two fingers provide a practical starting point.
For a thumber, hook the pad of your thumb inside the rim. Your fingers support the outside of the disc against the flight plate. Keep the thumb engaged without forcing it into an uncomfortable stretch.
In both grips, hold the disc securely enough that it leaves your hand deliberately. Excessive squeezing can make the release late and inconsistent. A wide distance-driver rim may feel excellent for a backhand yet awkward when your thumb has to carry the grip.
Wet plastic makes that problem worse. Carry a towel, dry your hand, and check the rim before throwing. A premium plastic that survives tree hits is useful only if you can release it cleanly.
Stability changes the rotation timetable
Overhand flight is more complicated than “overstable goes left.” The disc launches near vertical, rolls through changing orientations, moves sideways, and descends. Tomahawks and thumbers generally trace opposing patterns when thrown with the same hand.
More overstable discs commonly take longer to complete that rotation. Less overstable discs often turn over sooner, which can help a developing thrower complete the flight with less height or power.
That makes the most overstable disc a poor automatic recommendation. If it reaches the ground before rotating through the intended shape, its theoretical distance potential does little for you.
Speed, glide, turn, and fade remain useful comparison tools, but manufacturers do not rate these molds specifically for overhand flight. A turn rating of 0 does not mean the disc stays upright throughout a thumber.
Height is part of the shot
An overhand needs room for its rotation. Insufficient flight height can leave the disc striking the ground on edge before it reaches the intended landing orientation.
Before choosing the shot, inspect the entire overhead corridor. A branch directly above your release matters just as much as the canopy near the basket. Limited overhead clearance can make a lower forehand, backhand pitch, or deliberate roller the better option.
Do not solve every incomplete flight by throwing harder. First check whether the disc has enough height, whether its stability suits your power, and whether you released it at the intended angle.
Landing behavior determines the useful target
A steep landing can produce a small stop, a skip, or a substantial roll. Ground slope, roots, pavement, and the disc’s landing orientation all influence the result.
Aim for a landing area rather than assuming the disc will stop directly beneath its highest point. Near out-of-bounds, an edge landing deserves particular caution: a successful escape can become a penalty if the disc stands up and rolls.
Practice on the surfaces you actually play. A flight that finishes quietly in soft grass may travel much farther after contact with hard, dry ground.
Comfort sets the power ceiling
Overhand throwing can place substantial demands on the shoulder and elbow. A useful escape shot does not require a maximum-effort run-up.
Start with general movement, comfortable shoulder motion, and several easy throws. Build intensity gradually instead of making your first thumber the hardest throw of the round. No warm-up guarantees injury prevention.
If the movement causes pain, stop. Persistent shoulder or elbow symptoms warrant advice from a qualified clinician. Buying a lighter disc or changing molds does not make painful mechanics acceptable.
Four Discs Worth Comparing
The table lists manufacturer flight numbers in speed/glide/turn/fade order. The suggested weights are shopping targets within these molds’ usual offerings, subject to availability. They are starting points for selection, not manufacturer prescriptions for overhand technique.
| Product | Manufacturer flight numbers | Rim width | Plastic and suggested shopping weight |
|---|---|---|---|
| Innova Firebird | 9 / 3 / 0 / 4 | 19 mm | Star or Champion; 165–175 g |
| Discraft Flick | 12 / 3 / +1 / 5 | 21 mm | Elite Z; 165–175 g |
| Innova Eagle | 7 / 4 / -1 / 3 | 17 mm | Star or Champion; 165–172 g |
| Innova Banshee | 7 / 3 / 0 / 3 | 18 mm | Champion; 165–175 g |
These are selection comparisons, not distance rankings. Disc shape, plastic, wear, release angle, and your grip can matter more than a one-point difference in the flight numbers.
Innova Firebird: The strongest starting point for a dedicated overhand slot
The Innova Firebird combines speed 9, glide 3, turn 0, and fade 4 with a 19 mm rim. It offers substantial overstability without the wider grip of a speed-12 driver.
For a player building a repeatable tomahawk or thumber, that combination makes the Innova Firebird a sensible first comparison. Its relatively low glide and strong resistance to turning in conventional flight also make it useful for forehand utility shots and windy approaches.
Choose Champion if durability and retaining the initial flight are priorities. Star is also durable and may provide a more comfortable grip for some hands. Plastic stiffness and surface feel vary, so neither blend is automatically better in every temperature.
A 165–170 g example is worth considering if a heavy utility driver feels difficult to accelerate smoothly. Move toward 173–175 g when you already throw comfortably and want a heavier option. Weight alone does not determine wind performance.
The compromise is timing. The Innova Firebird may rotate too slowly for a short, low-ceiling escape. It also cannot eliminate landing rolls. Buy it for a flight shape you can practice, rather than assuming its reputation guarantees a controlled finish.
Discraft Flick: A specialized choice for a secure overhand grip
The Discraft Flick carries speed 12, glide 3, turn +1, and fade 5. Its 21 mm rim makes it the widest option here, and its strong overstability places it at the demanding end of this comparison.
The Discraft Flick deserves attention when a thrower wants a resistant, deliberate overhand rotation and can supply the height and speed to use it. Its low-profile shape can appeal to players who dislike deeper-feeling discs.
Elite Z plastic suits a utility disc that will encounter trees and rough landings. It is durable, but grip remains personal; smooth premium plastic can become troublesome when wet.
Start around 165–170 g if you want to assess the mold without automatically choosing maximum weight. A heavier example makes more sense after you know that the rim fits your thumb and fingers.
The compromise is substantial: the Discraft Flick is easy to overbuy. Its speed rating does not promise extra distance, and its stability can leave an underpowered throw unfinished. If your current disc already hits the ground before rotating, this is unlikely to be the simplest fix.
Innova Eagle: A practical learning option with broader everyday use
The Innova Eagle has speed 7, glide 4, turn -1, and fade 3. Its 17 mm rim offers a narrower grip than either the Innova Firebird or Discraft Flick.
That narrower rim is the main buying argument. A player struggling to hook a thumb securely under a wider wing may find the Innova Eagle easier to handle. Its less extreme stability also makes it worth comparing when more resistant discs require too much height.
Star or Champion in approximately 165–172 g is a reasonable starting range. Both plastics offer durability for repeated practice, while the choice between them should follow your grip preference.
The Innova Eagle also earns space through ordinary fairway work. It can cover controlled backhand and forehand lines, so learning an overhand does not require buying a disc with only one purpose.
Its compromise is a different rotation timetable. It may move through the overhand shape sooner than a more overstable utility driver, limiting some high, extended flights. Wear can also change that timing. For learning short escapes, however, easier rotation can be useful rather than inferior.
Innova Banshee: A slower utility alternative
The Innova Banshee is rated speed 7, glide 3, turn 0, and fade 3, with an 18 mm rim. It sits between the narrower Innova Eagle and the faster Innova Firebird in grip dimensions.
Consider the Innova Banshee when you want an overstable fairway driver without moving immediately to speed 9 or 12. Champion plastic provides a durable option for wooded courses and repeated utility use.
A 165–170 g example offers a sensible starting point for controlled practice. Players who already prefer heavier fairways can compare examples nearer 175 g, provided the release stays comfortable.
The Innova Banshee’s appeal is manageable speed and a straightforward utility role. It can complement a neutral fairway while covering overhand escapes and conventional shots that need dependable fade.
The compromise is overlap. If your bag already contains an Innova Firebird that fits your hand, adding an Innova Banshee may offer little practical benefit. Buy the different rim feel or a demonstrated flight gap, rather than collecting two discs for an indistinguishable job.
How to Throw the Tomahawk
Begin from a standstill in an open field. Choose a modest target distance and hold the disc nearly vertical with the tomahawk finger placement described above.
Turn your body enough to allow a comfortable throwing motion, then bring the disc through an overhead path. Let your torso and arm work together. Avoid trying to manufacture the entire throw with a hard elbow snap or an exaggerated wrist twist.
Release upward with room for the disc to rotate, and allow a natural follow-through. You do not need to keep the arm rigidly above your head; the motion should stay comfortable rather than forced into a fixed shape.
For the first session, change one variable at a time. Keep your stance and effort similar while making small release-angle adjustments. Watch where the disc first moves sideways, when it rotates, and which orientation reaches the ground.
Inconsistent release angles often come from changing grip pressure, leaning differently, or accelerating harder on each attempt. A repeatable short throw teaches more than several unrelated maximum-distance attempts.
How to Throw the Thumber
Switch to the thumber thumb placement: thumb hooked inside the rim, fingers supporting the opposite side. Establish the grip before raising your arm.
Use the same restrained standstill approach. Release the disc near vertical through a smooth overhead motion, keeping enough grip pressure that it does not slip early.
Expect a flight pattern that generally mirrors your same-hand tomahawk. Learn its actual direction in an open field before using it beside a road, water, or another fairway. Left-handed throws reverse the corresponding right-handed patterns.
If the thumb slips, check moisture and rim fit before squeezing harder. A narrower rim may help more than a more overstable mold.
If the disc lands before completing its rotation, compare a higher release or a less overstable disc at comfortable effort. Do not assume the only answer is more force.
Wind, Landing Rolls, and What to Skip
Wind affects an overhand throughout its rotation because the disc repeatedly presents different surfaces to the air. A crosswind can push the sideways movement farther than expected or change the landing angle. Headwinds and tailwinds also alter the flight; ordinary backhand wind rules do not translate neatly through every stage.
Practice first in calm conditions, then compare light wind from different directions. Strong wind is a poor setting for learning a new grip beside a tight landing zone.
Skip maximum-weight discs as an automatic badge of control. A 175 g driver that encourages a strained release is a worse choice than a lighter disc you can throw smoothly.
Skip ultra-overstable molds when you lack the height to finish their rotation. Also skip buying several molds simultaneously: four unfamiliar flights make it harder to identify whether the disc or your release caused the result.
Finally, skip the overhead entirely when the ceiling is blocked or the landing slope strongly favors a roll toward trouble. Shot selection is part of technique.
Buying Advice: Start With One Disc and One Job
First define the job: a short wooded escape, a higher shot over a barrier, or a dedicated longer overhand. Then select for grip fit and usable rotation at that height.
For many players, the Innova Firebird is the clearest dedicated utility starting point. Choose the Innova Eagle if rim comfort and easier rotation matter more. Compare the Innova Banshee for a slower overstable option, and reserve the Discraft Flick for a demonstrated need for stronger resistance.
Buy one example from an authorized retailer before purchasing multiples. Once its flight becomes useful, a matching backup can reduce disruption if the original is lost. Remember that premium plastic still wears, and repeated hard impacts can change both stability and rotation timing.
For the lower escape that follows, “Kastaplast Berg: An Honest 90-Day Review” is a relevant companion when considering a low-glide approach disc. If the remaining shot calls for a conventional putt or approach, “Kastaplast Reko: A Full Review of the Versatile Putt and Approach Disc” covers another useful category.
FAQ
Is a tomahawk easier than a thumber?
It depends on hand comfort and throwing motion. Try both at low effort with the same disc. Begin with whichever grip stays secure and produces a repeatable release without discomfort.
Do you need an overstable disc?
No. Overstable discs are useful for many overhand lines, but a less overstable disc may complete its rotation with less height or power. Choose according to the flight you can produce.
Why does the disc roll after landing?
It may be landing on edge, contacting a slope, or striking a hard surface. Adjust the landing area and release, and compare a different stability if necessary. No mold guarantees a roll-free finish.
How far should a beginner throw an overhand?
There is no useful universal target. Start with short standstill throws that let you observe the full flight. Add distance only while maintaining a comfortable motion and predictable landing area.
Can one disc cover tomahawks and thumbers?
Yes. Start with one disc to learn how the two grips change its path. Add another only when you can identify a specific need, such as faster rotation under a lower ceiling.
This article contains affiliate links. BasketBound may earn a commission when you purchase through them, at no additional cost to you.
This article contains affiliate links. BasketBound may earn a commission when you purchase through them, at no additional cost to you.
Related Articles
- Best Disc Golf Discs for Windy Conditions Buyer's Guide 2026
- Best Glow Plastic for Night Disc Golf
- How to Throw a Hyzer Flip in Disc Golf: Complete Technique and Disc Selection Guide
- Best Disc Golf Discs for Cold Weather: The Ultimate Winter Buyers Guide
- Taming the Sidearm: A Buyer's Guide to Mastering the Disc Golf Forehand
Keep reading
- more on MVP Glitch review -- is it just a gimmick
- what to know about Putting Form Fundamentals
- the full write-up on Kastaplast Berg
Where to Buy
Affiliate links: as an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases.
